Georgie Burkhardt refuses to accept that the body that the sheriff
brought back to Placid is her sister. Sure, the corpse has red hair and
is wearing the same dress that her sister owned, but the body is too
decomposed to convince Georgie that her older sister Agatha is really
gone. Even though her mother and grandfather accept that Agatha is dead,
Georgie wants to retrace the steps that her sister took when she ran
away weeks ago to find out what really happened. Putting her own life
in danger, Georgie sets off on a journey that unveils her own role in
her sister's disappearance.
Set in 1871 Wisconsin, Amy
Timberlake's novel combines historical fiction with mystery. Though it
takes a while to gain momentum, One Came Home is dark and
intriguing novel that can appeal to a wide audience. Georgie is strong
protagonist who is not completely likable, which might bother some
readers. Those who can endure the slow start and don't mind Georgie's
gritty demeanor will be rewarded with beautifully written story.
An independent school library dedicated to bringing literature and learning to middle school students.
Showing posts with label Mystery. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mystery. Show all posts
Monday, April 8, 2013
Thursday, February 21, 2013
Book Review: HOLD FAST
The Pearls face more misfortune when masked men break into
their apartment, take all of their valuables, and smash everything that is
left. Without money or an income, Summer
has no choice but to take her family to Helping Hand Shelter. The Pearls quickly learn how difficult
life in a homeless shelter can be.
The lack of privacy, long lines, and constant illnesses in the shelter wear
on the family. Early knows that
her father would never purposely leave them or break the law. If she can just figure out the clues
Dash left behind, she can find her father and clear his name. Then the family can get back to
working on fulfilling their dreams.
Blue Balliett’s new novel does an excellent job of
illustrating the hardships of the working poor and the homeless. Hold Fast shows how crippling these
hardships can be for children.
Early is the target of ridicule at school because her peers know where
she is living, Jubie becomes sick from the illnesses spread at the shelter, and
it seems impossible for Summer to find a job without decent day care options
for her son. Despite all the
wonderful services Helping Hand offers, the Pearls would be stuck in this
shelter without the support of Dash.
The reader wants the Pearls to succeed, and Balliet’s novel would surely
lead to more empathy for the homeless.
Though the Pearl family’s story is very compelling, the
mystery in Hold Fast is not. Early’s investigation is a dry read,
and Balliet takes the last thirty pages of the novel to explain what happened
to Dash. I’ve had trouble selling
students on Balliet’s novels, and I fear I will experience the same problems
with Hold Fast. As a former
teacher, Balliet wants to incorporate poetry and math into her stories, which
is laudable, but the result is often laborious for readers.
3.5 out of 5 Stars
Grades 5 and up
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)